About PAG
News
Documents
Media Comments
Links
Questions
Compensation Proposals
Involving your MP
 

Campaigning for Pensions Justice

This is the official website of the Pensions Action Group (PAG), which campaigns for justice for those who lost some or all of their company pension when their schemes were wound up.

***************************************

ANDREW PARR
9 Sept 1944 - 22 Jan 2019
R.I.P.

Andrew at one of our trademark PAG demonstrations

It is with great sadness that we announce the passing last Tuesday morning of our great friend and leader, Andrew Parr, aged 74, after an illness bravely fought in his usual stoic and pragmatic style.

Andrew was one of the main instigators and founders of the Pensions Action Group, following the collapse in 2002 of his employer, Allied Steel and Wire (ASW) in Kent with another plant in the same group suffering the same fate in South Wales.

Andrew, a Chartered Engineer responsible for the Steelworks process controls, and his colleagues not only lost their jobs but then found that they had lost most, if not all, of their work pensions that they had contributed to all their working lives. Andrew was part of a small group of workers who were not going to accept this sitting down, and he and others quickly rallied further support locally and nationally by raising awareness of the situation. He contacted his local MP, Derek Wyatt, who too became very active, and so the formation of the Pensions Action Group began.

Ros Altmann, a pensions expert who advised the Government, went to South Wales with the BBC's Panorama Programme to highlight the plight of ASW Cardiff and then met with Andrew Parr and his colleagues to work out how to get the Government to arrange compensation for their 'stolen' pensions. It soon became clear that ASW workers were not the only people to find themselves in this horrific and financially devastating predicament. Several other companies throughout the UK had also closed down with thousands of people now affected. A meeting was called at Portcullis House in Westminster, in September 2003, and this was publicised by the Press, including the Mail on Sunday. Many representatives of various companies whose pension schemes had failed attended this meeting to see what could be done. Andrew and his co-founders were joined at the meeting by Derek Wyatt and Ros Altmann.

This meeting really instigated the well-publicised activity of the now Pensions Action Group, with Andrew firmly at the helm. Ros Altmann arranged a Fringe Meeting at the Labour Party conference in Bournemouth in September 2003 to explain why the Government should compensate, at which Andrew spoke eloquently about the plight of those affected. This was followed by the first 'Stripped of Our Pensions' demonstration, which attracted further media coverage. An action plan was drawn up at a meeting famously held in the Reading Services on the M4 in November 2003, which was followed by a further rendezvous in Leicester, another meeting in the House of Commons and the first active sit-down protests in Oxford Street and later outside New Scotland Yard, where our 'Pensions Robbery' was reported.

The campaign continued alongside political and legal proceedings. Andrew's calm and intelligent manner meant that he was the mainstay in the technical negotiations that followed, while his dear wife Alison, always supportive, joined the now hundreds of protestors at numerous protests including two all-night vigils outside Downing Street and the Houses of Parliament, at the various Political Party Conferences and wherever we could find a sympathetic ear. Andrew enjoyed joining in with all of the 'Stripped of Our Pensions' trademark demonstrations, clearly and very effectively designed to raise public awareness. Indeed, Andrew and Alison travelled to all corners of the UK to deliver the message of how being robbed of our pensions was the biggest social injustice of modern times.

Over the following years Andrew steadfastly helped lead the group. He single-handedly set up the Pensionstheft website, which enabled other scheme members to join the PAG and keep in touch with each other to find out about the latest news or upcoming demonstrations. Andrew attended the ECJ, Parliament, the Parliamentary Ombudsman and even the High Court. He also met every Pensions Minister to demand action. This culminated with the supportive Parliamentary Ombudsman's report 'Trusting in the Pensions Promise', which clearly blamed successive governments for allowing the collapse of pension schemes with insufficient funds to pay the members their pensions. Andrew, with three others, put his own house at potential risk of costs being awarded against them when he and three others took the Government to court in the 'Robbins and Others' legal case. Ros Altmann had arranged for lawyers to represent PAG on a no-win, no-fee basis, but the Government refused to guarantee that it would not pursue Andrew for its legal costs if PAG lost. Andrew would not be cowed into submission and continued with the case, which was about the Government's rejection of its own Ombudsman's findings and recommendations, and also about compliance with Article 8 of the EU Insolvency Directive. Thankfully, the case was successful and costs were not awarded. However, having lost in the High Court, the Government then decided to launch an Appeal against the ruling and once more refused to agree to cover its own costs if PAG lost. Andrew was determined not to be frightened away and continued with the Appeal case, which once again resulted in a PAG victory.

The Government faced significant opposition in Parliament, including from its own MPs and trade unions, which led to a decision to create the Pensions Protection Fund (PPF) in 2004. However, this would only help victims of any future pension fund failures and did not apply to schemes that had collapsed before 2005. To stave off Parliamentary defeat, the Government tried to pretend it would help the pre-2005 victims with a 'Financial Assistance Scheme' but Ros Altmann's research calculations showed this would not help more than a tiny proportion of those who had lost their pensions and each would receive a small fraction of their losses. So Andrew and the PAG, with continued lobbying, campaigning and media support, had to fight once more to improve the Financial Assistance Scheme (FAS) to provide assistance to help all those in his group. Andrew never stopped campaigning and fighting for proper improvements. Eventually, he and the PAG succeeded, although the current scheme benefits would not be won until December 2007, when Peter Hain (Secretary of State) and Mike O'Brien (Pensions Minister) finally gave in to Andrew and the PAG's arguments. Andrew had skilfully and patiently worked to achieve these results and at last the FAS benefits were aligned with those of the PPF.

Andrew and his fellow campaigners still carried on to try and restore some of the many benefits from their original schemes that were not included in the FAS, or the PPF. This legal work involved Andrew up to last year and the PAG campaign will continue this fight. We know that Andrew will be watching us and leading us from above.

Andrew's leadership of the PAG was simply outstanding. He was very articulate, passionate, witty, decisive, informative, intelligent, motivational and tolerant. He worked closely with Ros Altmann, later herself to become a Pensions Minister, to support all the work of the PAG. Ros was so convinced by the injustice of the pensions situation, and was so passionate about helping Andrew and all those who had suffered the pension losses through no fault of their own, that she put her own career on hold for five years to help lead the struggle for pensions reform and recompense for those affected. On hearing of Andrew's passing Ros said 'Andrew did so much for so many and always had a smile, a wise word and kind heart. His Bravery and determination helped all of us and his work has enriched the lives of many people who never even knew him.'

Andrew was also key in helping Ros to motivate the media to highlight the just cause of the PAG struggle, giving countless TV interviews and featuring in hundreds of newspaper articles. Jeff Prestridge, Personal Finance Editor of the Mail on Sunday was an early recruit, and is still supportive. Jeff summed up his involvement with Andrew in this way: 'Andrew was a great individual who was key in the battle for pensions justice. Someone I had huge respect for and who gave a lot in the quest to help others. As far as my dealings with him are concerned, he was a journalist's dream. Articulate, modest and always willing to give a comment. Kind and gentle. A vital cog in the PAG wheel.'

Thankfully, following his dedication and leadership of the PAG, Andrew was able to enjoy some years of retirement before he became ill, travelling with Alison and enjoying her company along with their three sons Jamie, Nicholas and Simon, and their six grandchildren. Andrew was also very heavily involved in the Church near his home in Sheerness, and was a respected and very valued member of the Institute of Electrical Engineers.

Andrew will always have a place in all our hearts, he will be very sorely missed, but the memories of his wonderful, cheerful and positive company will help heal our sadness at this time.

Our thoughts and condolences go out to Alison and Andrew's family and friends.

Pensions Action Group
25 January 2019

Andrew's funeral was held on 21st February at Minster Abbey on the Isle of Sheppey (ME12 2HE) with PAG members in attendance. Baroness Altmann gave one of the addresses. The family have set up a donation page in Andrew’s name with contributions being directed towards his wish that Minster Abbey can be floodlit. Anyone wishing to make a donation can visit gofundme.com/lightuptheabbey and complete the online application.

***************************************

About the Pensions Action Group



Click here to see the latest PAG leaflet

We were promised (by the Government) that our pensions would be safe "whatever happens to your employer" but that was a lie. More and more people discovered to their horror that, when their employer went bankrupt, they had lost not only their job but also their pension. Some people even lost what the Government was pleased to call the "Guaranteed Minimum Pension". This could happen even if the scheme met the Minimum Funding Requirement, because the Government had set it too low; and some people with solvent employers lost their pensions too when their schemes were closed, because the Government had left a loophole in the regulations

Fighting back

The primary focus of the PAG is to address the shortcomings within the Financial Assistance Scheme (FAS), which was introduced to provide assistance to those of us who had lost most of their occupational pensions when their schemes closed down.

Government headlines proclaim that recipients of FAS will receive 90% of their company pension, but the reality is that we will receive less than 50% over our retirement period. Our latest leaflet describes the outstanding issues we have. The most important of these is the lack of future indexation for any part of your fund that was accrued before 1997, which for most of us is the majority our pension. The only portion that will attract any indexation is the period from 1997 until the start of wind up of your scheme. Most schemes started to wind up in 1999 or 2000, so this is a very small proportion of your pension.

The lack of indexation over the rest of your lifetime will be devastating.

Please peruse the website to see for yourself the long campaign that we have been running, and the efforts that have been made to try to achieve justice for those affected by this scandal.

Find fellow scheme members



If you want to make contact with members of your pension scheme, it can be difficult because neither trustees nor the FAS/PPF will hand out personal details. PAG doesn't have members from every scheme but we do cover many of them and if you write to us at contact-us@pensionstheft.org we will try to put you in contact with other members of your scheme.

AEA Technology


Members of the AEAT scheme are setting up a members group. There are more details here.

We are very interested in hearing from people who have been caught in a similar position. If you are interested in joining our action group, or finding out more, send an e-mail to:  
contact-us@pensionstheft.org

 
Top